Governor Cuomo’s updated green energy goals, that became law on Jan. 1, 2020, fast tracks the state’s energy production coming from renewable sources by 2040.


The Climate Leadership and Community Protection Act has set New York’s target of obtaining 70% of its energy from green sources by 2030 and 100% renewables by 2040.


Previously Governor Cuomo wanted to make New York a “National Leader” by having renewables provide 50% of the state’s electricity by 2030 – a Goal known as “50 by 30”.


This means an increase in electricity prices because of mandated payments from you, to fund the projects. Avangrid and other developers have a history of partnering with NY State agencies to win funding for their projects.


In addition, to date, no commercial wind project in New York state has been built without a PILOT agreement that provides significant property tax relief to the developer.



articles, publications


YOUR MONEY -  MANDATES AND SUBSIDIES

______________________________________
featured recommended reading:


July 16, 2018

WIND COSTS WILL BLOW NORTH

by Ken Girardin
Upstate New York ratepayers will pick up more than half the multi-billion-dollar tab for a massive offshore wind turbine project that will provide very costly power for Long Island and New York City.
https://www.empirecenter.org/



June 1, 2020

by Robert Bryce
In New York and New England, Wind Energy Projects Are “Like Siting Landfills. Nobody Wants Them.”  New York is becoming a wind-energy plantation for New England.


"New Englanders like the idea of wind energy they just don’t want any wind turbines in New England. So they are putting them in New York."
https://www.realclearenergy.org










______________________________________



October 26, 2021
Congress eyes $235B in clean energy subsidies. Here they are
https://www.eenews.net


October 13, 2021
Europe’s Energy Crisis Underscores The Dangers Of The Proposed Clean Electricity Performance Program
https://www.forbes.com


June 17, 2021
Why Was $66 Billion Spent on Renewables Before the Texas Blackouts? Because Big Wind and Big Solar Got $22 Billion in Subsidies
https://www.realclearenergy.org


April 20, 2021
Renewable Energy Boom Risks More Blackouts Without Adequate Investment In Grid Reliability
https://www.forbes.com/


April 1, 2021
Biden’s American Jobs Plan Aims to Overhaul Clean Energy Economy
https://nawindpower.com/


December 27, 2020
Why Is Solar Energy Getting 250 Times More In Federal Tax Credits Than Nuclear?

https://www.forbes.com


March 30, 2021
…a renewable energy tax incentive has come under fire for squeezing the county out of tens of millions of dollars each year.

https://www.bakersfield.com/


January 25, 2021

Cuomo's renewable energy boon to New York City building owners

https://www.politico.com


January 9, 2020
Progressive Eco-Group Admits It: Renewable Energy Is a Hoax that Benefits its Greenie Elmer Gantries like Al Gore
https://www.americanthinker.com


January 29, 2019
N.Y. Lawmakers Propose Legislation In Support Of Existing Renewable Energy Facilities - North American Windpower
https://nawindpower.com

December 1, 2018
Are wind turbines really good for economy, environment?
http://www.advertiser-tribune.com/opinions/


August 11, 2018

Wind and Solar Energy: Good for Nothing... understanding the subsidies provided to wind and solar.

https://www.americanthinker.com


August 5, 2018
Four of NYS Thruway's costly wind turbines stand idle. Why?
https://buffalonews.com


2018 Large-Scale Renewables RFP
NYSERDA has launched its second annual request for proposals to help accelerate progress towards the Clean Energy Standard mandate.
https://www.nyserda.ny.gov/


April 1, 2017

NEW! increase to fee on your electric bill, brought to you by NYSERDA and the Clean Energy Standard:
ESRM charges effective 4/1/2017


August 24, 2016

Costing out Cuomo’s green tax
https://www.empirecenter.org

September 27, 2016

Green Overload - New York State’s Ratepayer-Zapping Renewable Energy Mandate
https://www.empirecenter.org


April 30, 2017

Wind power companies get by with a little help from their friends - By Perry White
http://www.watertowndailytimes.com/news


April 2, 2017
Nuclear, renewable energy subsidy costs affect ratepayers starting Saturday, April 1st
http://www.watertowndailytimes.com


March 27, 2017
Hiding the Increase
How Governor Cuomo is masking a huge energy-tax hike in the name of “consistency.”
https://www.city-journal.org/

Thursday, February 02, 2017
SunEdison Shareholder Uncovers Billions Of Dollars In Taxpayer Money Hidden In Bankruptcy
http://cohoctonwindwatch.blogspot.com/


March 9, 2017

Iberdrola Warns Of The Risk From Trump To US Renewables’ Growth Plan
http://thecorner.eu/

March 03, 2017
PSC covers up “clean energy” cost.
State regulators last week shot down efforts by utilities to show ratepayers the amount by which their electric bills are being driven up by New York’s new Clean Energy Standard.
http://www.empirecenter.org/


June 6, 2016
Wind-Energy Sector Gets $176 Billion Worth of Crony Capitalism… including Iberdrola. It takes enormous amounts of taxpayer cash to make wind energy seem affordable.
http://www.nationalreview.com/


Cash in the wind: New York’s wind-power giveaway
https://www.wind-watch.org


March 17, 2017
Subsidised Wind & Solar Set to Quadruple German Power Prices
https://stopthesethings.com/


Big Wind's Bogus Subsidies - Giving tax credits to the wind energy industry is a waste of time and money.  Despite being famous for touting the idea that the rich don’t pay their fair share of taxes, investor Warren Buffet seems to be perfectly fine with receiving tax breaks for making investments in Big Wind. 

https://www.usnews.com/


January 16, 2017 - In New York, Wind And Solar Get Double Their Value In Subsidies
http://dailycaller.com


February 10, 2017

The IRS expanded the two-year development window to four years [from two years to give] … developers countless ways in which to secure the full PTC and never experience the phased-down PTC in the years 2017, 2018, and 2019.

This essay is the second in a series aimed at exposing abuses by the Obama administration in its effort to force wind power on the public.

https://www.masterresource.org


January 10, 2018
Your Pension Isn't Safe From NY Governor Andrew Cuomo
https://townhall.com/columnists

Hopkinton meeting - Iberdrola rep explaining one of the subsidies provided to the company: Federal Production Tax Credit

(starts at minute 4:45)

Our series of graphics illustrating how your money is used to fund industrial wind projects.

PAID FOR BY YOU - INDUSTRIAL WIND SUBSIDIES

"Mike, we are a green energy company, but the green stands for money." 

- Jeffrey Skilling,

President, Enron

(to reassure one of Enron’s coal executives)

March 7, 2017

Ibrudrola representative explaining sale of electricity and need for a partner to build this project.

Visit our follow the money... "how big wind works" page for graphics that illustrate this topic and see how you pay for funding.
 

TAX EQUITY MARKET


Tax equity financing, a scheme based on special tax breaks and gaming the corporate income tax of a highly taxed corporate partner.


Wind developers rely on “tax equity” to finance their projects. Tax equity is based on the wind project’s predicted cash flow and expected federal tax benefits. In 2017, Keith Martin, a lawyer at the law firm Norton Rose Fulbright, explained that tax equity “accounts currently for 50% to 60% of the capital cost of a typical wind farm and 40% to 50% of the capital cost of a typical solar installation.”


articles


March 30, 2021
New Legislation Aimed At Giving Developers Direct-Pay Option for PTC Projects
https://nawindpower.com/


April 1, 2021
Opinion - Such a gift. Since the mid-1990s the wind power industry has made a living off of a federal tax credit (the Production Tax Credit --PTC) earned according to a formula for whatever power they generated – whether that power was needed by the grid or not – and even if their bidding price in wholesale power markets was zero!

The wind farm owners could turn those tax credits into cash by selling them (typically) to another corporation that needed the tax credits more than the wind farm owner. The buyer of the tax credits would be a profitable corporation that could use the tax credits against the tax it owed. Wind farm owners seldom show significant taxable income because they don’t really need to make money the old-fashioned way.  Instead, they rely on these exchangeable tax credits as a primary source of income – a credit against the tax they owe – even if they don’t owe any tax!  A tax credit becomes all the “income” necessary, and, of course,  a tax credit is no taxable income! Nice!

So what you have in effect is the wind industry living off a federal subsidy in the form of a tax credit that can be sold. That is where the “profit” is in the wind business. It is not a profit in any traditional business sense, but it is real money and it has drawn hundreds of developers – large and small – into the wind business to enjoy the benefit of something generally not found in the business world – a sure thing.


This tax credit mechanism is an indirect way for the federal government to pay the wind power business to exist. Wind power is thus really not a business; it is a federal program run by private contractors. And these private contractors are not paid directly by government appropriations. They are paid “off budget” through the Tax Code.

(I know! – but this is all true. You can’t make this up.)

But now Senators Carper, Heinrich and Whitehouse (among the wind lobby’s best friends in Congress) want the Tax Code amended to allow wind generation owners (and the other renewables owners) to skip the step of “earning” the PTC and marketing it to buyers. They are saying that for new wind projects, wind developers should be free to simply calculate what their tax credit will be and then the government will just issue a check for that amount. Done. Why make this complicated? Why should wind owners have to wait for their money?

(The accountants who work for wind developer/owners will like the straightforward simplicity of this. But perhaps the Wall Street investment bankers who package these tax credits and find buyers for them, and take their cut, won’t like the fact that their services will no longer be needed.)



May 1, 2020
What Engie's tax equity deal tells us about financing renewables
https://www.greenbiz.com


April 28, 2020
Scale-up of Solar and Wind Puts Existing Coal, Gas at Risk
https://about.bnef.com/blog

NY energy export to New England

YOUR WAGES, PAID AS TAXES

nimby

videos

INDUSTRIAL WIND QUOTES:

INDUSTRIAL WIND QUOTES:

"For example, on wind energy, we get a tax credit if we build a lot of wind farms. That's the only reason to build them. They don't make sense without the tax credit." 

- Warren Buffet

What you need to know about Industrial Wind Farms

Northern NY Wind

handouts